Research article
Open Access

Short- and long-term results of low cost trauma training in a low-income resource-poor country [Version 2]

Ninos Oussi[1], Mitra Sadeghi[2], Javeria S. Qureshi[3], Charles Mabedi[4], Peter Elbe[1], Lars Enochsson[5]

Institution: 1. Division of Surgery, Department of Clinical Science, Intervention and Technology (CLINTEC), Karolinska Institutet, Stockholm., 2. Department of Vascular Surgery, Västmanlands Hospital Västerås., 3. Department of Surgery, Cook County Hospital, Chicago, IL., 4. Kamuzu Central Hospital, Department of Surgery, Lilongwe., 5. Department of Surgical and Perioperative Sciences, Division of Surgery, Umeå University, Umeå.
Corresponding Author: Dr Ninos Oussi ([email protected])
Categories: Assessment, Learning Outcomes/Competency, Students/Trainees, Teaching and Learning, Clinical Skills
Published Date: 16/10/2018

Author Revision Notes

The manuscript is revised partly based on the reviewers comments.
Additional references.
Statistical analysis added to the Methods section.
The Conclusion more brief and concise.

Abstract

Introduction: Malawi is among the world’s least developed countries. There are 2.1 physicians per 100 000 people and a high trauma-related mortality and morbidity. The lack of healthcare resources requires essential high capacity trauma training at a low cost.

 

Methods: A one-week trauma course was conducted at the Kamuzu Central Hospital in Lilongwe, Malawi. 15 students (13 interns and 2 chief nurses) attended the course. They were trained in initial trauma care, triage and basic practical procedures. Thereafter, evaluated through an identical multiple-choice exam, pre- (PRE) and post-course (POE), following a similar exam 6 months post-course (6MPOE). Prior to, and after the course a confidence-based questionnaire was completed.

 

Results: The participants presented significantly higher test-scores after the course in both POE (26.2±3.2 vs. 21.8±3.1; p>0.001) and 6MPOE (25.7±2.4 vs. 21.8±3.1; p 0.003). We also identified the nurses to improve significantly after the course. The highest score of improvement was 27.3%. Higher confidence scores were noticed after the course.

 

Conclusion: This study shows that any healthcare personnel in a low-income setting could benefit from a designed course in trauma management. Thus, we emphasize that healthcare staff undertake similar course to orient towards correct management and assessment of initial trauma patients.

 

Keywords: Trauma in Africa; Trauma training; Sub-Saharan Africa; Trauma team training

Introduction

Today there are over 4 million injury-related deaths each year worldwide, where 90% of the injuries occur in low and middle-income countries (Wesson et al., 2014). Trauma related deaths are almost three times the number of deaths from HIV/AIDS, malaria, and tuberculosis combined (Kotagal et al., 2014). According to the Global Burden of Disease, injuries cause 11.2% of all disability adjusted life years worldwide (Kotagal et al., 2014). The incidence of trauma-related morbidity and mortality is increasing and the highest injury trauma-related mortality is seen in sub-Saharan Africa (MacLeod et al., 2011). Africa has, due to the high volume of surgical disease, the highest percentage per head of surgical disability adjusted life-years (DALYs) in the world (Lavy et al., 2011).

 

Depending on the countries economical standard one finds differences in probability of survival.  Studies shows that a severely injured patient with mid-range Injury Severity Score has six-times higher risk of mortality in a low-income country, like Ghana, compared to a high-income country, like USA (Mock, Joshipura and Goosen, 2004).

 

Malawi is one of the poorest countries in the world with 65% of the population living below 1 US dollar per day (van Amelsfoort et al., 2010) and 93 US dollars in total expenditure per capita on healthcare in 2014 (World Health Organization, 2018) . Like many low-income countries there is paucity of skilled healthcare providers with 2 physicians and 59 nurses per 100 000 people (World Health Organization, 2008; Qureshi et al., 2013).

 

Due to the shortage of healthcare workforce in Malawi, surgeons have started to educate clinical officers (non-physician clinicians). To improve clinical care, surgeons invested in both regional surgical education but also collaboration with different international partners (Qureshi et al., 2013).

 

In Malawi, like in many developing countries about half of the injured patients are within the reproductive ages, in other words; the economically productive segment of the society (Schultz et al., 2007).  Injuries result in a financial burden for the individual as well as the society. However conversely, prior studies have shown young people are most likely to gain full recovery if they receive the correct management and care. Reduction in injury mortality rates in low and middle-income countries to the level of high income countries through better trauma care could save over 2 million lives per year worldwide (Kotagal et al., 2014). A reduction in mortality rate has also been demonstrated when training pre-hospital trauma care situated in Assyria (todays northern Iraq) and Cambodia, provided the training is given in conjunction to the local needs (Husum, Gilbert and Wisborg, 2003). A reduction in mortality rate in severely injured patients has also been seen, in a capital hospital in Rwanda, after initiating focused trauma education courses (Petroze et al., 2015). Therefore, the training of hospital staff in trauma management is even more crucial in a setting where there is high trauma-related morbidity/mortality and a resource poor staff restricted environment. A recent study also suggest implementation of a cost-effective and appropriate trauma training curriculum for resource-poor environments (Anderson et al., 2018).

 

In high-income countries the Advanced Trauma Life Support (ATLS) has been used to standardize and improve trauma care (Quansah, Abantanga and Donkor, 2008). ATLS, which is managed by the American College of Surgeons, has been spread over more than 80 countries, educating more than 1 million providers so far (ACS, 2018).  The start-up cost for an ATLS course is about 80 000 US dollars, which is not favourable in a poor setting (Quansah, Abantanga and Donkor, 2008). The ATLS course is also designed with a high technology hospital in mind. In low technology and resource constricted hospitals with limited referral possibilities there is a need for alternative educational approaches (Nolan, 2005). Several studies of trauma training among healthcare staff in low-income countries have shown positive results (Schultz et al., 2007; Quansah, Abantanga and Donkor, 2008; Douglas et al., 2010; MacLeod et al., 2011; Kurdin et al., 2018). However, there is a need for follow-up to assess the gained knowledge long term. Here we demonstrate the effectiveness of low cost trauma training to improve healthcare providers trauma management abilities long term.

Methods

We conducted a one-week initial trauma management and triage course in May 2012 at Kamuzu Central Hospital (KCH), Lilongwe, Malawi. KCH is an 800-bed hospital that serves the central region of Malawi with a population of about 5 million (Samuel et al., 2010). 

 

Thirteen interns from the surgical department and two Surgery Emergency Room (S-ER) nurses attended the course. The group was homogeneous consisting of 53% female participants and an age ranging from 20-30 years. The inclusion criteria for the participants were all the interns undergoing their surgical rotation at that time due to the current situation in the local setting. At the request of the hospital administration, we also included the two responsible S-ER nurses who served as managers for the emergency room. Before the inclusion they all accepted to take part in the course and the study.

 

The course was based on ATLS trauma care principles and practical manoeuvres. These covered topics in the standard Airway/neck immobilization (A), Breathing (B), Circulation (C), Disability (D) and Exposure (E) format. The course lectures in ABCDE were held through collaboration with the local staff and expatriate doctors working in Malawi. Patient triage was held as group seminars with discussion of trauma related cases, where every participant was involved.

 

We incorporated the theoretical parts with practical procedures and went through fundamental practical procedures such as neck stability, insertion of chest tubes (on goat cadaver), and immobilization of extremities, vascular access and suturing techniques. X-ray interpretations were adapted to the local resources and facilities. Extra attention was given to paediatric injuries and burn management because of the high amount of paediatric trauma related injuries and burns in the region.

 

The participants were then evaluated through an identical 33 multiple choice exam pre- (PRE) and post-course (POE) and made a pre/post-course questionnaire for confidence assessment. We were also able to examine them 6 months post-course (6MPOE) with a new 33 multiple-choice exam to evaluate their gained knowledge over time. Unfortunately, we were not able to examine all 15 students as a result of rotations in different district hospitals, insufficient means of communication like no addresses etc., and thus only 11 were examined 6 months post-course (6MPOE).

 

Statistical analysis

IBM SPSS version 23 was used for statistical analysis. Data are presented as mean and standard deviation. Paired-samples T test was used for statistical analysis comparing PRE to POE and 6MPOE. Statistical significance was set at p <0.05.

Results/Analysis

A total of 15 students, 13 doctors and 2 nurses, returned the multiple-choice exam with 33 questions pre- and post-course but also 6 months post-course. Only 11 doctors participated the 6 months post-course.

 

The interns had significantly higher test scores after the course in both POE (26.2±3.2 vs. 21.8±3.1; p>0.001) and 6MPOE (25.7±2.4 vs. 21.8±3.1; p 0.003), which is equivalent to previous studies [3]. The improvement range was from 0-27.3% pre- to post-course and 6MPOE from -3 to 21% (Table 1).

 

Table 1: Students (n = 15) exam results; pre-course (PRE), post-course (POE) and six months post-course (6MPOE).

 

 

PRE

POE

6MPOE

1

18

24

 

2

23

26

27

3

21

28

21

4

13

19

 

5

20

29

25

6

24

25

25

7

24

26

25

8

24

28

 

9

24

27

23

10

25

29

29

11

23

27

25

12

24

30

29

13

21

21

26

14

22

24

 

15

21

30

28

 

One of the nurses improved her knowledge with 18% and had similar POE-score as some of the interns. In similar studies like this the highest gain of scores was in the group with the lowest pre-course results and in our setting, this applied to the two nurses.

 

The confidence score of the participants was increased by 12% after the course. The written course evaluation showed that all were satisfied with the course and recommended that we should include all the interns and even nurses for future courses (Table 2; Table 3).

 

Table 2: Self-assessment Survey (score 1-7).

 

1.

I’m certain that I can understand the most difficult concepts that are being presented during the course.

2.

I’m certain that I can understand basic terms and facts being brought up during the course (understanding the meaning of the lectures/stations).

3.

I’m certain that I can understand the most complex procedures being taught.

4.

I’m certain that I will succeed at the skills stations.

 

5.

I’m certain that I will master the skills taught during the course (succeed with the exercise).

 

Table 3: Self-assessment test score: overall test score (n = 15), pre- and post-exam score.

 

Question

Pre-exam

Post-exam

1

5.8

6.8

2

6.5

6.8

3

5.6

6.6

4

6.3

6.7

5

6.5

6.8

 

The total expenditure on this course was calculated to about 800 US dollars, including material, food and beverage. As the lecturers were mostly local (including the foreign lecturers working at KCH at the moment) there were no expenditures on the salaries. The two Swedish lecturers responsible for the course had salaries from their own employer. This amount is therefore 9 times less the amount of money payed for the two foreign doctors to travel from Sweden to Malawi and arrange the course, and its over 100 times less than setting up an ATLS course (Figure 1).

 

Figure 1: The course expenditures in USD.

Discussion

This study shows that healthcare providers in low-income countries can benefit from trauma training catering to their situation. It is important to include different professional cadres since trauma care is complex and all staff involved should have the same goal in initial management and understand the flow in this chain. In a resource poor setting, staff is required to fill roles they may not fill in a resource rich setting due to the lack of adequate manpower.

 

Interestingly, the two nurses in this study were in the group who gained the most knowledge, although, no major conclusions can be drawn with such a low sample, it shows that staff healthcare providers with less previous trauma experience are more likely to gain the most knowledge. Therefore, it is important to include nurses as well as clinical officers, who serve as non-physician in bigger parts of sub Saharan Africa.

 

Most importantly, participants retained the knowledge 6 months later. This study was unique in the sense that we could evaluate the participants also after 6 months. This indicates that short-term training can have a long-term effect.

 

The confidence scores correlate with increased performance of new skills. The participants had high scores in general and showed increased confidence after the course. Unfortunately, as a cause of economic issues and lack of staff we couldn’t extend the group of students. It’s also difficult for the department to stay without some of their staff for a whole week. For future studies we have to be aware of these types of problems and consider a different strategy to gather a bigger group of staff.

 

The next step is to incorporate more local lecturers into the course and make it part of the intern/nursing curriculum at KCH. It would be most interesting to see if the trauma-care improves over time at KCH as well as at the referring district hospitals by regular trauma training of the interns. We need to start placing injury prevention as a major goal for public health management and adjust trauma training to the local settings. There is a need for general improvement in trauma management for all medical staff regardless of degree.

 

Limitations The limitations of this study are the low number of participants, and also the relatively high number of drop-out rate (27%) due to difficulties reaching them for the 6 months follow up (6MPOE). For future studies it would be more beneficial to include more participants or conduct a multi-centre study.

Conclusion

This course is similar to an ATLS course covering initial management of trauma patients but in contrast to ATLS it was adjusted to the local settings. By using mainly local doctors instead of international doctors as lecturers the course could be given at a lower cost.

 

All participants thought the course should include all the interns at KCH as well as be given at an earlier stage of the internship.

Take Home Messages

  • Healtcare providers in low-income countries can benefit from trauma training without increasing expenses. 
  • Educating trauma management to the whole team and not only doctors leads to better patient care. 
  • The participants showed increased confidence after the course. 
  • Short-term training can have a long-term effect.

Notes On Contributors

Oussi, Ninos* - MD, PhD-Candidate, General Surgeon and Senior Consultant Surgical Urologist

Sadeghi, Mitra* - MD, PhD-Candidate, General Surgeon, Vascular Surgery Residence

Qureshi, Javeria S - MD, MPH, Assistant Professor, General Surgeon

Mabedi, Charles - MD, Urology Residence

Elbe, Peter - MD, PhD-Candidate, Senior Consultant General Surgeon, Endoscopist

Enochsson, Lars - MD, PhD, Assoc. Professor, Senior Consultant Surgeon, Endoscopist

 

*Contributed equally to the manuscript.

Acknowledgements

We thank all who participated in the study for their time, helpfulness, and insight. Special thanks go to Professor Emeritus Åke Andrén-Sandberg, Borrby, Sweden and also Dr Arturo Muyco and Dr Carlos Valera at the Kamuzu Central Hospital, Department of Surgery, Lilongwe, Malawi for their guidance and support.

Bibliography/References

ACS (2018) ACS Advanced Trauma Life Support. In: Surgeons ACo editor. Available at: https://www.facs.org/quality-programs/trauma/atls/about (Accessed: 10 September 2018).

 

van Amelsfoort, J. J. C. et al. (2010) ‘Surgery in Malawi – the training of clinical officers’, Tropical Doctor, 40(2), pp. 74–76. https://doi.org/10.1258/td.2009.090068

 

Anderson, G. A. et al. (2018) ‘Development of a Comprehensive Trauma Training Curriculum for the Resource-Limited Environment’, Journal of Surgical Education, 75(5), pp. 1317–1324. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2018.02.014

 

Douglas, R. J. et al. (2010) ‘Improving trauma care in India: a recommendation for the implementation of ATLS training for emergency department medical officers’, International Journal of Emergency Medicine, 3(1), pp. 27–32. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12245-009-0148-1

 

Husum, H., Gilbert, M. and Wisborg, T. (2003) ‘Training pre-hospital trauma care in low-income countries: the “Village University” experience’, Medical Teacher, 25(2), pp. 142–148. https://doi.org/10.1080/0142159031000092526

 

Kotagal, M. et al. (2014) ‘Health and Economic Benefits of Improved Injury Prevention and Trauma Care Worldwide’, PLoS ONE. Edited by A. Mahal, 9(3), p. e91862. https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pone.0091862

 

Kurdin, A. et al. (2018) ‘TEAM: A Low-Cost Alternative to ATLS for Providing Trauma Care Teaching in Haiti’, Journal of Surgical Education, 75(2), pp. 377–382. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsurg.2017.08.010

 

Lavy, C. et al. (2011) ‘State of Surgery in Tropical Africa: A Review’, World Journal of Surgery, 35(2), pp. 262–271. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-010-0885-6

 

MacLeod, J. B. A. et al. (2011) ‘Evaluation of Trauma and Critical Care Training Courses on the Knowledge and Confidence of Participants in Kenya and Zambia’, World Journal of Surgery, 35(1), pp. 9–16. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-010-0810-z

 

Mock, C., Joshipura, M. and Goosen, J. (2004) ‘Global strengthening of care for the injured’, Bulletin of the World Health Organization, 2004(82 (4)), p.1.

 

Nolan, J. P. (2005) ‘Advanced trauma life support in the United Kingdom: time to move on’, Emergency Medicine Journal, 22(1), pp. 3–4. https://doi.org/10.1136/emj.2004.018507

 

Petroze, R. T. et al. (2015) ‘Can Focused Trauma Education Initiatives Reduce Mortality or Improve Resource Utilization in a Low-Resource Setting?’, World Journal of Surgery, 39(4), pp. 926–933. https://doi.org/10.1007/s00268-014-2899-y

 

Quansah, R., Abantanga, F. and Donkor, P. (2008) ‘Trauma training for nonorthopaedic doctors in low- and middle-income countries’, Clin Orthop Relat Res, 466(10), pp. 2403–12. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11999-008-0401-6

 

Qureshi, J. S. et al. (2013) ‘Addressing Malawi’s surgical workforce crisis: A sustainable paradigm for training and collaboration in Africa’, Surgery, 153(2), pp. 272–281. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.surg.2012.08.004

 

Samuel, J. C. et al. (2010) ‘Hospital-based injury data in Malawi: strategies for data collection and feasibility of trauma scoring tools’, Tropical Doctor, 40(2), pp. 98–99. https://doi.org/10.1258/td.2009.090009

 

Schultz, C. R. et al. (2007) ‘Development of a Hospital-Based Trauma Registry in Haiti: An Approach for Improving Injury Surveillance in Developing and Resource-Poor Settings’:, The Journal of Trauma: Injury, Infection, and Critical Care, 63(5), pp. 1143–1154. https://doi.org/10.1097/TA.0b013e31815688e3

 

Wesson, H. K. H. et al. (2014) ‘The cost of injury and trauma care in low- and middle-income countries: a review of economic evidence’, Health Policy and Planning, 29(6), pp. 795–808. https://doi.org/10.1093/heapol/czt064

 

World Health Organization (2008) WHO country cooperation strategy at a glance: Malawi, Institutional Repository for Information Sharing. Available at: http://www.who.int/iris/handle/10665/136935 (Accessed: 10 September 2018).

 

World Health Organization (2018) WHO International. Available at: http://www.who.int/countries/mwi/en/ (Accessed: 10 September 2018).

Appendices

None.

Declarations

There are no conflicts of interest.
This has been published under Creative Commons "CC BY-SA 4.0" (https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/)

Ethics Statement

Malawi does have an ethics committee; Malawi National Health Research Council (NHRC) however, we did not require ethics approval as the study only looked at improving providers knowledge base and did not directly affect patients.

External Funding

This paper has not had any External Funding

Reviews

Please Login or Register an Account before submitting a Review

Trevor Gibbs - (08/05/2019) Panel Member Icon
/
Delivering high quality and up-to-date informative courses within difficult circumstances is very difficult and a sensitive issue. I feel that the authors should be congratulated on their efforts here. They have tried to adapt their input to the local needs and also used local resources to keep down costs. I particularly feel that the longer term evaluation shows the true value of the course, even though it was a relatively short course. I would recommend this paper to all concerned with the delivery of such courses in resource constrained countries.
Richard Hays - (15/03/2019) Panel Member Icon
/
This paper reports a nice example of adapting a successful international course to a local situation, using local resources wherever possible to make the course possible. The outcome is good and I particularly like the evaluation after 6 months, which is more meaningful than the more commonly used end-of-course evaluation. Are further evaluation strategies planned, including looking at patient outcomes?
Possible Conflict of Interest:

I am Editor of MedEdPublish

Ken Masters - (08/03/2019) Panel Member Icon
/
This is a well written version of the paper, and the author have addressed the previous reviewers’ concerns. The problems of delivering good medical care under these circumstances is well described, and the need for such a course is clearly explained.

The standard Pre- and Post-test indicated the short-term impact of the course; I liked the fact that this was followed up with another test 6 months later (the fact that not all candidates could take the later test is unfortunate, but to be expected, especially given the circumstances). Combining a test with the confidence evaluation is particularly useful, as only one or the other would not complete the picture.

Figure 1 is probably not entirely necessary, but it does serve to emphasis the massive cost savings for those readers who are unfamiliar with the financial situation of the area.

I look forward to seeing papers dealing with further iterations of this course. If the authors do follow up with further courses and papers, it might be useful if they were to supply, as an appendix, a course outline/curriculum.